Last post, I mentioned two Stuart Palmer pieces from the April 1930 issue of Ghost Stories: one I had, and one I didn't. Well now I have the second piece: "Between Two Worlds," the original version of "How Lost Was My Father?" from Fate July 1953.
You can read "Between Two Worlds" here.
This story of a man who mysteriously disappeared while walking in a field is based upon three Ambrose Bierce tales: "The Difficulty of Crossing a Field," "An Unfinished Race," and "Charles Ashmore's Trail"—mostly upon the first and third. All three of these tales can be found in the Bierce collection Can Such Things Be?.
I've now read both the Ghost Stories and Fate versions of the story; Palmer did revise it a little for its second publication, changing some details and expanding upon others. The housekeeper character Mammy Sue becomes Sukie; a pivotal seance moves from Brooklyn to Philadelphia. But the storylines are identical, and the Fate version reuses some of the key illustrations from the original. It retains the first-person narration of the Ghost Stories version, as well.
Reading it again, it struck me how eerie this story is. The narrator was a little girl when her father vanished literally into thin air; losing a parent so irrevocably would be one of the scariest experiences possible for a child. And the idea that her father might have spent half a century stuck in some kind of alternate-dimension limbo is just....brrrrrr.
It was also nice to read this story after having read several of Palmer's drier "non-fiction" articles (by which I mean his retellings of previously published paranormal accounts). I'd forgotten how atmospherically written Palmer's supernatural tales are. This one has a much quieter ending than stories like "Seven Gray Wolves" or "The Monster in the Cellar," but it was still lovely to read. I hope you enjoy it, too.